Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Emerikol" data-source="post: 8237053" data-attributes="member: 6698278">When you say that my own opinion that X is not immersive is wrong then you are denying my perspective and experience.This is where you are dead wrong.&nbsp; My approach gives me X and I can't get it playing the other ways.&nbsp; At least where X is immersive, a feeling of verisimilitude.&nbsp;&nbsp; It is ridiculous that you are denying how I feel about something.&nbsp; A person who is not immersed due to X where X is absolutely anything in the universe is someone who is not immersed due to X.&nbsp; Immersion is a personal thing.&nbsp;&nbsp; You can't seem to get that.&nbsp; We aren't debating approaches having merit in general.&nbsp; If people are enjoying an approach then it has merit for THEIR games.&nbsp; That is true of anything.&nbsp;&nbsp; Use what you like and discard what you don't.&nbsp; I have tried over and over to explain to you WHY I FEEL AS I DO.&nbsp; I am not saying anything about how YOU FEEL AS YOU DO.&nbsp;&nbsp; I have repeated this a lot so you should just repeatedly read the previous sentence until you get it.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Emerikol, post: 8237053, member: 6698278"] When you say that my own opinion that X is not immersive is wrong then you are denying my perspective and experience. This is where you are dead wrong. My approach gives me X and I can't get it playing the other ways. At least where X is immersive, a feeling of verisimilitude. It is ridiculous that you are denying how I feel about something. A person who is not immersed due to X where X is absolutely anything in the universe is someone who is not immersed due to X. Immersion is a personal thing. You can't seem to get that. We aren't debating approaches having merit in general. If people are enjoying an approach then it has merit for THEIR games. That is true of anything. Use what you like and discard what you don't. I have tried over and over to explain to you WHY I FEEL AS I DO. I am not saying anything about how YOU FEEL AS YOU DO. I have repeated this a lot so you should just repeatedly read the previous sentence until you get it. [/QUOTE]

Verification