Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Emerikol" data-source="post: 8247489" data-attributes="member: 6698278">I think that for me at least I would be as unsatisfied if the GM made it up at that moment as I would if the PC made it up.   I will readily say that historically my rejection of campaigns has been more about GM's making too much stuff up on the fly than it has been about players authoring the fiction.   I suspect my belief that a GM can't effectively make up something so central to the game in a believable way is why I am hesitant about players doing it.Face it, the average GM is more knowledgeable and more invested than the average player.   Now there are players who are every bit as invested.  GM's play too and of course there are just really good players.  So I said "on average".   So my doubt that a good GM can pull it off just continues on to players doing it.</blockquote>