Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.
Enchanted Trinkets Complete--a hardcover book containing over 500 magic items for your D&D games!

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Dr. Strangemonkey" data-source="post: 2380621" data-attributes="member: 6533">Really? That's great to know.  I was wondering why the field marshall was having all the men in my local draft militia march and fire in large scale formation today.  Well, your knowledge certainly is at the crux of this disagreement.  What precisely have you read on Mongol battles?  I can't account for your idea of noteworthy without a larger discussion of your tastes.  Mostly I'm just impressed that you don't find the phenomenal success of what was essentially a Mongol exploratory expedition into Eastern Europe perfectly astonishing.  Perhaps picking a particular Mongol campaign to analyze might provide a means of both elucidating the strengths of the Mongols in combat and illustrating any number of prior points on this board?The Mongols were actually very good at preserving the domains they conquered, the disruption comes primarilly from the various episodes of reconquest.  It is not the Mongols, for instance, who really spelled the doom of the Sufis so much as the Mamelukes who replaced them.The lack of direct influence by the Mongols on the nature of warfare in the modern period is precisely why I think we've taken so long to catch up to them.  If the European powers had been able to combine field artillery with Mongol principles of mobility and battlefield control the horrors of WWI ideas of tactics might have been countermanded.A point by point breakdown of a Mongol campaign would be extremely helpful for this, but look at the tactics, organization, and strategy of a WWII army and ask yourself which they resemble more the Mongols or the Romans?Much of the excellence of the Mongols is only now being felt as we begin the process of recovering their legacy and discovering the nature of world systems in general, but that doesn't make it any less revolutionary or incredible.You've got some good points, but you're placing far too high a level of importance on legacy without considering the quality of the actual situations and technologies of the time.  History is as much about calamity and recovery as it is any sort of gradual progression.</blockquote>

Verification