Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Emerikol" data-source="post: 8224510" data-attributes="member: 6698278">I don't count it as a top ten issue but I also would not say that Eberron was ever core D&amp;D in terms of the implied game.&nbsp; It was a great change of pace with lots of wonderful ideas and it showed what a good DM could do in terms of hewing their own campaign.I do think the differences in Forgotten Realms and let's say Greyhawk 1e are pretty trivial.&nbsp; It's clearly the great wheel with very minor superficial tweaks for flavor.&nbsp; Eberron is what a DM does when he creates his own cosmology.&nbsp;&nbsp; Forgotten Realms is what happens when a DM buys a campaign setting and decorates it to make it his own.&nbsp;&nbsp; Also in 3e, Living Greyhawk was the implied setting.I do agree with you on 4e's setting not being a significant issue.&nbsp; I actually liked the change up.&nbsp; I wish every campaign setting did it's own cosmology.&nbsp; Cosmologies are fun.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Emerikol, post: 8224510, member: 6698278"] I don't count it as a top ten issue but I also would not say that Eberron was ever core D&D in terms of the implied game. It was a great change of pace with lots of wonderful ideas and it showed what a good DM could do in terms of hewing their own campaign. I do think the differences in Forgotten Realms and let's say Greyhawk 1e are pretty trivial. It's clearly the great wheel with very minor superficial tweaks for flavor. Eberron is what a DM does when he creates his own cosmology. Forgotten Realms is what happens when a DM buys a campaign setting and decorates it to make it his own. Also in 3e, Living Greyhawk was the implied setting. I do agree with you on 4e's setting not being a significant issue. I actually liked the change up. I wish every campaign setting did it's own cosmology. Cosmologies are fun. [/QUOTE]

Verification