Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Kaji" data-source="post: 1388724" data-attributes="member: 7738">Ok, My player is mad at me again. Here's the story:He is a paladin of Osiris (FR). At one point, he is given a n arrow of dragon slaying by another paladin. This paladin makes him swear that he will not sell it, because then it could be bought by bad guys and used to kill good dragons. They must either use it themselves to kill bad dragons, or give it to other good creatures. Got it? Seemed simply to me.Anyhoo, years later, they still have it. They have sent to meet an ancient blue dragon and get something from her (stuff, information?, they don't really know yet.). So, she comes out, and gives them a little roughing up to see how they take it. Our friend decides to pull out his arrow of dragon slaying, places it on the ground, and (wait for it)...offers it up as a sign of good will to the evil dragon.I was stunned. I was shocked. I was aghast. I also dropped his paladinhood on the spot. Well, he got pretty hot about that one (I'm mean, my guy would have remembered about the oath, blah blah blah...)The other party members did not forget. In fact, one tryed to stop him, but there was no time. I'm just looking to get a second set of eyes, as it were. I don't think I was too harsh, but sometimes it's easy to get carried away.Any thoughts</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Kaji, post: 1388724, member: 7738"] Ok, My player is mad at me again. Here's the story: He is a paladin of Osiris (FR). At one point, he is given a n arrow of dragon slaying by another paladin. This paladin makes him swear that he will not sell it, because then it could be bought by bad guys and used to kill good dragons. They must either use it themselves to kill bad dragons, or give it to other good creatures. Got it? Seemed simply to me. Anyhoo, years later, they still have it. They have sent to meet an ancient blue dragon and get something from her (stuff, information?, they don't really know yet.). So, she comes out, and gives them a little roughing up to see how they take it. Our friend decides to pull out his arrow of dragon slaying, places it on the ground, and (wait for it)...offers it up as a sign of good will to the evil dragon. I was stunned. I was shocked. I was aghast. I also dropped his paladinhood on the spot. Well, he got pretty hot about that one (I'm mean, my guy would have remembered about the oath, blah blah blah...) The other party members did not forget. In fact, one tryed to stop him, but there was no time. I'm just looking to get a second set of eyes, as it were. I don't think I was too harsh, but sometimes it's easy to get carried away. Any thoughts [/QUOTE]

Verification