Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="kigmatzomat" data-source="post: 2149279" data-attributes="member: 9254">Yup, we're disagreeing.&nbsp; Just to explain why I didn't feel it was gratuitous, since your campaign does not allow Detect Evil to work on non-supernaturals, aiding the evil Zhentish regime despite being under duress is essentially swearing allegiance.&nbsp; At that point he goes from &quot;possibly unwilling minion of evil&quot; to &quot;loyal and active servant of evil.&quot; As such, executing him is at worst a neutral act.&nbsp; (He's not an innocent but they aren't willing to make any personal sacrifices.)&nbsp; If you consider the fact that he could have earned his freedom by lying to the party, they might be willing to make a limited sacrifice since he could hook up with a unit that was nearby and get them killed.&nbsp; BTW: I did not mean to insult you in any fashion.&nbsp; I've got a half-dozen friends on necesary mind-altering medications and if anyone drifts too far out of my definition of &quot;rational&quot; it cues the &quot;are you taking your meds?&quot; sequence.&nbsp; There have been times in my life that after the fact I wished someone had said to me &quot;You're not acting normal.&nbsp; You should get some kind of help.&quot;</blockquote>

[QUOTE="kigmatzomat, post: 2149279, member: 9254"] Yup, we're disagreeing. Just to explain why I didn't feel it was gratuitous, since your campaign does not allow Detect Evil to work on non-supernaturals, aiding the evil Zhentish regime despite being under duress is essentially swearing allegiance. At that point he goes from "possibly unwilling minion of evil" to "loyal and active servant of evil." As such, executing him is at worst a neutral act. (He's not an innocent but they aren't willing to make any personal sacrifices.) If you consider the fact that he could have earned his freedom by lying to the party, they might be willing to make a limited sacrifice since he could hook up with a unit that was nearby and get them killed. BTW: I did not mean to insult you in any fashion. I've got a half-dozen friends on necesary mind-altering medications and if anyone drifts too far out of my definition of "rational" it cues the "are you taking your meds?" sequence. There have been times in my life that after the fact I wished someone had said to me "You're not acting normal. You should get some kind of help." [/QUOTE]

Verification