Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Numion" data-source="post: 1996547" data-attributes="member: 124">Didn't sound like his game was on life support. But for whatever reason one player wants to do something that results in another player losing his character. It's that simple. Does the game suffer more from the first player not getting to keep player 2 from playing his character, or does it suffer more from player 2 not getting to play his character? (If that made any sense..)Both choices have consequences in the future. Player 2, whose resurrection was given to a PC by choice of one player, can always make another character. Is he prone to doing grudge characters? Will that help the campaign? And really, if you argue that a PCs free will is untouchable by the DM, so should one also be free to create a character with a grudge towards one of the previous PCs. Player 1, if he does not get the NPC back he likes, is down one NPC. I just don't see this as a nearly as big thing as a PC. But then again, I usually have an idea for a backup PC ready incase my PC dies, so I'm not too attached to them either.</blockquote>