Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="jessemock" data-source="post: 1305169" data-attributes="member: 15694">Except that all creatures are susceptible to whatever technique you've developed with your Weapon Specialization, whether immune to Criticals or not.&nbsp; That's some technique!But suppose that this does have something to do with vital areas (though it affects creatures who supposedly don't have them):&nbsp; don't you find it odd that you know how to do this with only one weapon at a time?And that whatever techniques you've developed particular to your weapon affect all creatures equally, despite the fact that you may know nothing about their anatomies?I mean that you're interpreting Weapon Specialization to have the same process as Improved Critical, which is fine so far as it goes, but it continues with the same implications for the critical hit system, i.e. the attacker doesn't need to know anything about anatomy to cause a critical hit (or even to improve his ability to do so), yet susceptibility to critical hits is determined entirely by the particulars of a creature's anatomy.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="jessemock, post: 1305169, member: 15694"] Except that all creatures are susceptible to whatever technique you've developed with your Weapon Specialization, whether immune to Criticals or not. That's some technique! But suppose that this does have something to do with vital areas (though it affects creatures who supposedly don't have them): don't you find it odd that you know how to do this with only one weapon at a time? And that whatever techniques you've developed particular to your weapon affect all creatures equally, despite the fact that you may know nothing about their anatomies? I mean that you're interpreting Weapon Specialization to have the same process as Improved Critical, which is fine so far as it goes, but it continues with the same implications for the critical hit system, i.e. the attacker doesn't need to know anything about anatomy to cause a critical hit (or even to improve his ability to do so), yet susceptibility to critical hits is determined entirely by the particulars of a creature's anatomy. [/QUOTE]

Verification