Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="likuidice" data-source="post: 2096822" data-attributes="member: 12040"><p>they can add extra amusement to the game, or annoyance and disgruntled players. It all depends on how well theyre implemented. Currently our DM is using some horrific table that he rolls on whenever we roll a 1, no save, no way of avoiding it, roll a 1, get a result from &quot;weapon breaks&quot; to &quot;stab yourself&quot; &quot;stab your mate&quot; &quot;chuck weapon away&quot;. It's starting to get ridiculous, our weaponsgifted by the gods break nearly every session, we are already starting to go through magic weapons like we're fighing with glass bottles, and I'm seriously regretting taking 2 weapon fighting, 7 attacks each round, average of one broken weapon/stabbed ally/lost item every 3 rounds. Thankfully we don't have a monk, or he'd break his arm every 20 seconds, or punch himself in the face. It's like the higher level we are, the more inept we become. Fumble tables are fine if theres a reasonable chance of avoiding them, maybe based on Bab, with weapon focus/greater focus adding an extra +1 to your roll (seeing as it represents dedicated training with one weapon). Maybe D20 + BAB + weapon focus vs DC15 check, with a natural 1 always a failure.</p></blockquote><p></p>

[QUOTE="likuidice, post: 2096822, member: 12040"] they can add extra amusement to the game, or annoyance and disgruntled players. It all depends on how well theyre implemented. Currently our DM is using some horrific table that he rolls on whenever we roll a 1, no save, no way of avoiding it, roll a 1, get a result from "weapon breaks" to "stab yourself" "stab your mate" "chuck weapon away". It's starting to get ridiculous, our weaponsgifted by the gods break nearly every session, we are already starting to go through magic weapons like we're fighing with glass bottles, and I'm seriously regretting taking 2 weapon fighting, 7 attacks each round, average of one broken weapon/stabbed ally/lost item every 3 rounds. Thankfully we don't have a monk, or he'd break his arm every 20 seconds, or punch himself in the face. It's like the higher level we are, the more inept we become. Fumble tables are fine if theres a reasonable chance of avoiding them, maybe based on Bab, with weapon focus/greater focus adding an extra +1 to your roll (seeing as it represents dedicated training with one weapon). Maybe D20 + BAB + weapon focus vs DC15 check, with a natural 1 always a failure. [/QUOTE]

Verification