Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="DEFCON 1" data-source="post: 5827954" data-attributes="member: 7006">No.. what you're saying is that it's okay for us to go against what the game is telling us about hit points and just 'make up' or 'house-rule' new concepts and explanations about what hit points are... but it's not okay that you would have to do it.You could just as easily make up or house-rule the game fiction to &quot;fix&quot; the issues you have with it.&nbsp; Like to say that Second Winds are actually magical Cure Light Wounds potions that everyone has a good supply of (enough that they can use them every encounter).&nbsp; Easy enough.&nbsp; Makes all the sense in the world and &quot;fixes&quot; your problem.But the fact that you could do that but would rather not... just means that you chose not to play 4E.&nbsp; Which is fine.&nbsp; I have no problems with that.&nbsp; But that doesn't mean that because I DID play 3E and willingly bit my tongue and accepted the disconnect because I just wanted to play the game... doesn't mean therefore I'M the one who needs to compromise and go back to the way things used to be.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="DEFCON 1, post: 5827954, member: 7006"] No.. what you're saying is that it's okay [I]for us[/I] to go against what the game is telling us about hit points and just 'make up' or 'house-rule' new concepts and explanations about what hit points are... but it's not okay that you would have to do it. You could just as easily make up or house-rule the game fiction to "fix" the issues you have with it. Like to say that Second Winds are actually magical Cure Light Wounds potions that everyone has a good supply of (enough that they can use them every encounter). Easy enough. Makes all the sense in the world and "fixes" your problem. But the fact that you [I]could[/I] do that but would rather not... just means that you chose not to play 4E. Which is fine. I have no problems with that. But that doesn't mean that because I [B]DID[/B] play 3E and willingly bit my tongue and accepted the disconnect because I just wanted to play the game... doesn't mean therefore [B]I'M[/B] the one who needs to compromise and go back to the way things used to be. [/QUOTE]

Verification