Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Arnwyn" data-source="post: 4753912" data-attributes="member: 7701">Yet, from what I remember, she gave absolutely zero indication that this was the guy who took her baby, not even mentioning &quot;oh guys - btw, he was the one who nabbed Alex. Just sayin', as you go on and on debating as to if he is even a member of the Others in the first place&quot;. Not even facial expressions, tone, nothing. (Can anyone go back and definitively see if she expressed any form of recognition?)I'm going to have to go with &quot;reaching&quot;. Sorry.See above.Not recognize the guy that stole her baby? Highly unlikely. And note that any time one must explain away logical inconsistencies, flaws, and retcons with &quot;she's crazy&quot; is a significant blemish on the show.That would be the &quot;making things up&quot; I alluded to with my previous post.*shrug* It was a retcon. While it made for a good, tight episode, it hurt it as a (already scattershot) series. If we're lucky they'll come up with something to make it fit (as Lost is in the enviable position of being able to re-insert what scenes they need when they need it).</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Arnwyn, post: 4753912, member: 7701"] Yet, from what I remember, she gave absolutely zero indication that this was the guy who took her baby, not even mentioning "oh guys - btw, he was the one who nabbed Alex. Just sayin', as you go on and on debating as to if he is [i]even a member of the Others in the first place[/i]". Not even facial expressions, tone, nothing. (Can anyone go back and [i]definitively[/i] see if she expressed any form of recognition?) I'm going to have to go with "reaching". Sorry. See above. Not recognize [i]the guy that stole her baby[/i]? Highly unlikely. And note that any time one must explain away logical inconsistencies, flaws, and retcons with "she's crazy" is a significant blemish on the show. That would be the "making things up" I alluded to with my previous post. *shrug* It was a retcon. While it made for a good, tight episode, it hurt it as a (already scattershot) series. If we're lucky they'll come up with something to make it fit (as Lost is in the enviable position of being able to re-insert what scenes they need when they need it). [/QUOTE]

Verification