Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Imaro" data-source="post: 4705369" data-attributes="member: 48965">Huh? Really huh? You don't think there are DM's who only create level-appropriate challenges (again not the same as same-level encounters) and then contrive to make sure the PC's only encounter them, or as Thasmodius has stated, he does, adjust them on the fly. I'm not saying anything is wrong with this style, but honestly to claim it doesn't exist is absurd.&nbsp;Also please excuse me if I don't put much stock in unsupported claims of &quot;what most players and/or DM's do&quot;. Give me some evidence (besides anecdotal) and maybe I'll take your claims a little more seriously.&nbsp;&nbsp;Uhm ok, if that's what you believe... again that's great for you, but what exactly are you arguing then, since it's only &quot;theoretical&quot; for you.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Who said anything about what 3e or 4e state in their rulebooks? what does this have to do with editions, it's about playstyles, so why are you even bringing this up?&nbsp;&nbsp;Ok, I agree... but what does the 4th ed. DMG have to do with this discussion? Whatr exactly are you arguing here?</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Imaro, post: 4705369, member: 48965"] Huh? Really huh? You don't think there are DM's who only create level-appropriate challenges (again not the same as same-level encounters) and then contrive to make sure the PC's only encounter them, or as Thasmodius has stated, he does, adjust them on the fly. I'm not saying anything is wrong with this style, but honestly to claim it doesn't exist is absurd. Also please excuse me if I don't put much stock in unsupported claims of "what most players and/or DM's do". Give me some evidence (besides anecdotal) and maybe I'll take your claims a little more seriously. Uhm ok, if that's what you believe... again that's great for you, but what exactly are you arguing then, since it's only "theoretical" [B]for you[/B]. Who said anything about what 3e or 4e state in their rulebooks? what does this have to do with editions, it's about playstyles, so why are you even bringing this up? Ok, I agree... but what does the 4th ed. DMG have to do with this discussion? Whatr exactly are you arguing here? [/QUOTE]

Verification