• NOW LIVE! Into the Woods--new character species, eerie monsters, and haunting villains to populate the woodlands of your D&D games.

Worn out scenes

So I was watching Minority Report recently. It was pretty good, BTW. However, there was a scene in it that made me roll my eyes. It also reminded me of a scene in Troy, which I haven't even seen. I have read the first half of the script for Troy and I know there is a scene in the beginning of that movie that makes my eyes roll, too.

So what are they?
1. In minority report (and dozens of other action movies, most notably in my mind is the Dirty Harry movies) there is a running fight/chase sequence where the "high action" of the chase is interspersed with SILLY situational comedy. The chase often takes the main characters across roof tops until the fall/jump through a skylight/window and interrupt some random people doing something silly. From here the chase usually runs next door, or downstairs to another equally random and silly group of people who do NOT react to the situation in the way real people would.
For example, when the cops chasing Tom Cruise fly into the apartment the woman can be heard saying "get out! what re you doing? are you crazy?" Stuff like that.
Now if cops, chasing a criminal, suddenly burst through your living room window right now, what would you say and do?

2. In Troy there is a scene where Brad is sleeping. He's supposed to be with the army. But he's stayed behind and slept in. So they send a messenger to get him. The messenger sneaks into his tent, but Brad... er. Achilles... is such a great and keen warrior that he is already awake and feigning sleep. He is already aware of the intruder, and suddenly, without warning, his hand strikes out and catches the intruder in his vice like grip!! (cue dramatic music)

Yawn..

How many movies have I seen that scene in? God, save me from lame, hackneyed movie scenes.

I want to see a scene that depicts a great warrior’s experience by showing his exaggerated startle response when someone sneaks up on him. Exaggerated Startle Response is a symptom of PTSD and is a common reaction among people that have experienced combat and excessive physical violence. Lets see brad shout in alarm, spring from the bed in a flash, rip the kids arm off, and beat him with it before he even realizes what he's done.

Anyway, are there any hackneyed movie scenes that you've seen way too many times in way too many movies?

I'm not really trying to be negative here, just trying to find out what people are tired of seeing. Minority Report was a great movie, even with the lame chase scene.
 

log in or register to remove this ad


Bloodstone Press said:
Now if cops, chasing a criminal, suddenly burst through your living room window right now, what would you say and do?

If people suddenly burst through your living room window right now, are you sure you'd recognize them as police before you reacted?

I want to see a scene that depicts a great warrior’s experience by showing his exaggerated startle response when someone sneaks up on him. Exaggerated Startle Response is a symptom of PTSD and is a common reaction among people that have experienced combat and excessive physical violence.

Been done - in X-Men. Wolverine wakes up startled and runs Rogue through before he realizes what's actually going on.

Anyway, are there any hackneyed movie scenes that you've seen way too many times in way too many movies?

Sometimes, I wish. I tend to throttle my disbelief into unconsciousness when I walk into a movie, so that I don't pay as much attention to the film on a meta-level. It often makes me into what others might call a less than discerning critic.
 
Last edited:

Umbran said:
If people suddenly burst through your living room window right now, are you sure you'd recognize them as police before you reacted?



Been done - in X-Men. Wolverine wakes up startled and runs Rogue through before he realizes what's actually going on.



Sometimes, I wish. I tend to throttle my disbelief into unconsciousness when I walk into a movie, so that I don't pay as much attention to the film on a meta-level. It often makes me into what others might call a less than discerning critic.

This is one of the things that drives my friends nuts, I can not turn off my disbelief. It's on 11 all the time when I watch a film. I notice every little flaw and it can really spoil a movie for me. I love when I can get "lost" in a movie. But it is a rare thing...

The most tired scene idea for me is that every bloody character in the movie knows the main character... it's like they are the most popular human in the world...
 

Personaly for me the scene that I am tired of in action movies is where the hero(s) spend the whole movie killing there way through his henchment left and right without a second thought but when they get to the BBEG they do the If I kill you I'll be just like you thing. If your gona have a problem killing the truely evil guy shouldnt you have a problem killing simple lackeys?
 

My personal pet peeve is the "I've just hit the villain in the genitals, and I've got him rolling on the ground in pain, so NOW I'm going to run away from him." :mad: That one ticks me off, because if someone's stalking me, and I've just sucker-punched him, I'm going to press the advantage and keep stabbing / eye-gouging / strangling the :):):):):):) until he's DEAD! It's not called "FIGHT or flight" for nothing!
 

I agree with Henry. That's been bothering me in a number of movies lately.

My most abused scene would be the "OH, MY GOD! THE MONSTER ISN'T DEAD!!!, that seemingly HAS to be included in every horror movie since "Carrie". Setting things up for a sequel is one thing. Trying to shock audiences with something that is in every movie is just feeble and tired.
 
Last edited:

In all fairness to Minority Report, it was supposed to represent a future where people are much more de-sensitized to seemingly-arbitrary police actions like that. They weren't saying "this is how people really would react", but rather "this is how people might react, given the world they live in".

That having been said, yeah. The hero-falling-through-floor/wall/window-and-landing-in bathroom-while-neigbor-is-in-the-tub scene needs to be put out to pasture.

How about the "ending the movie by having a character sarcastically repeat a line that was used on them earlier in the movie" scene?
 

Or one of the characters standing over a dead friend/spouse/siblings, dropping to their knees and saying "NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!"
 

Galeros said:
Or one of the characters standing over a dead friend/spouse/siblings, dropping to their knees and saying "NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!"

Rather they should say something like "FIIIIINNNNNNAAAAALLLLY!!"

Starman
 

Into the Woods

Remove ads

Top