Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Jer" data-source="post: 7704332" data-attributes="member: 19857">That's a big part of it.&nbsp; But also because D&amp;D is unlike other adaptations and so it's hard to see how it can succeed.&nbsp; It's not a literary adaptation like &quot;Harry Potter&quot; or &quot;Lord of the Rings&quot;.&nbsp; It's not an adaptation of a beloved children's cartoon from the 1980s/1990s like &quot;Transformers&quot; or &quot;Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles&quot;.&nbsp; It's not an adaptation of the adventures of a long-running serialized comic book character like all of the Marvel movies or the Batman franchise.&nbsp; It's not even an adaptation of a video game like the Resident Evil movies.They're attempting to adapt a tabletop game to a movie.&nbsp; This is not an easy sell.&nbsp; Previous attempts to do this brought us &quot;Clue&quot; (a movie I love but was not a success) and &quot;Battleship&quot; (ugh).&nbsp; What's more, D&amp;D is a narrative game so on the one hand it seems like it would be easy to build a film narrative around something in the game and make it work, but so far there have been three D&amp;D movies and none of them have worked (though the second one was kind of hilarious in a &quot;Hercules the Legendary Journeys&quot; sort of way).I think this is why a lot of people say things like &quot;Why don't they just do Dragonlance?&quot; or &quot;Why aren't they doing the Drizz't stories?&quot;&nbsp; Because those would be literary adaptations and it's easy to see how they could be done (though I think they are problematic for their own reasons).&nbsp; The concern is that whatever is done with the D&amp;D movie it'll be a generic fantasy movie with the D&amp;D name slapped on it.&nbsp; Or if we're &quot;lucky&quot; a generic fantasy movie with a few fanservice namechecks thrown into the dialogue (i.e. a &quot;Why I haven't seen danger this severe since that time we fought those cultists of Elemental Evil - remember that one boss?&quot; sort of thing).I'm hopeful it turns out good but it's uncharted territory.&nbsp; You need a writer (or group of writers) who can come up with a screenplay that holds to the spirit of D&amp;D who don't really have a plot laid out before them to adapt.&nbsp; They're not doing something wholly original, but they aren't just taking someone else's vision and putting it on the screen.&nbsp; That's going to be hard, and you'll need some special people to do that.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Jer, post: 7704332, member: 19857"] That's a big part of it. But also because D&D is unlike other adaptations and so it's hard to see how it can succeed. It's not a literary adaptation like "Harry Potter" or "Lord of the Rings". It's not an adaptation of a beloved children's cartoon from the 1980s/1990s like "Transformers" or "Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles". It's not an adaptation of the adventures of a long-running serialized comic book character like all of the Marvel movies or the Batman franchise. It's not even an adaptation of a video game like the Resident Evil movies. They're attempting to adapt a tabletop game to a movie. This is not an easy sell. Previous attempts to do this brought us "Clue" (a movie I love but was not a success) and "Battleship" (ugh). What's more, D&D is a narrative game so on the one hand it seems like it would be easy to build a film narrative around something in the game and make it work, but so far there have been three D&D movies and none of them have worked (though the second one was kind of hilarious in a "Hercules the Legendary Journeys" sort of way). I think this is why a lot of people say things like "Why don't they just do Dragonlance?" or "Why aren't they doing the Drizz't stories?" Because those would be literary adaptations and it's easy to see how they could be done (though I think they are problematic for their own reasons). The concern is that whatever is done with the D&D movie it'll be a generic fantasy movie with the D&D name slapped on it. Or if we're "lucky" a generic fantasy movie with a few fanservice namechecks thrown into the dialogue (i.e. a "Why I haven't seen danger this severe since that time we fought those cultists of Elemental Evil - remember that one boss?" sort of thing). I'm hopeful it turns out good but it's uncharted territory. You need a writer (or group of writers) who can come up with a screenplay that holds to the spirit of D&D who don't really have a plot laid out before them to adapt. They're not doing something wholly original, but they aren't just taking someone else's vision and putting it on the screen. That's going to be hard, and you'll need some special people to do that. [/QUOTE]

Verification