Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Bullgrit" data-source="post: 5017138" data-attributes="member: 31216">I understand what you’re getting at, but when the transformation means/requires the DM to make all the expansion himself (even if suggested by the module author), does that really count as making the adventure a perpetual dungeon?I mean, if I design the whole city of Highport (which I did) for the module Slave Pits of the Undercity, does that make the published module a city adventure? The module text suggested the DM do this, just like the G modules suggested the DM expand beyond the given lair map.So I don’t think having a tunnel going off the printed map into darkness, and telling the DM, “Feel free to create more dungeon rooms off in that direction,” really counts to make something like the G modules, themselves, as published, into perpetual dungeons.Doesn’t Sunless Citadel and/or The Forge of Fury have a similar spot on the map and direction in the text to expand into the underdark? Surely that doesn’t make them mega-dungeons or underdark-excursion adventures.Bullgrit</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Bullgrit, post: 5017138, member: 31216"] I understand what you’re getting at, but when the transformation means/requires the DM to make all the expansion himself (even if suggested by the module author), does that really count as making the adventure a perpetual dungeon? I mean, if I design the whole city of Highport (which I did) for the module [i]Slave Pits of the Undercity[/i], does that make the published module a city adventure? The module text suggested the DM do this, just like the G modules suggested the DM expand beyond the given lair map. So I don’t think having a tunnel going off the printed map into darkness, and telling the DM, “Feel free to create more dungeon rooms off in that direction,” really counts to make something like the G modules, themselves, as published, into perpetual dungeons. Doesn’t [i]Sunless Citadel[/i] and/or [i]The Forge of Fury[/i] have a similar spot on the map and direction in the text to expand into the underdark? Surely that doesn’t make them mega-dungeons or underdark-excursion adventures. Bullgrit [/QUOTE]

Verification