Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Chacal" data-source="post: 638485" data-attributes="member: 1349">For those who think I'm penalizing a character, please remember thatI was talking about the situation where there was only a paladinrewards for surviving as a group are a different thing, as I said before, because what affects the group even if it's not affecting you directly, create a challenge , even for you and in that case I could  give XP.In the situation where someone walking alone sets traps that have no chance to affect him, Ireally think that there's no difference with walking in an empty corridor. And I don't give xp for just walking.Keep in mind that a challenge is not necessarily a risk, IMO (my lack of english vocabulary might explain if I use the term challenge wrong)if it's overcome by a clever plan that deserves XP for me.I still think that picking immunities is ok, and it helps a PC to do its part of the job in a group so that he deserves XP.But there's no way I'll give a standalone PC XP for fighting alone fire elementals just for the sake of it if he has fire immunity.If the paladin in the case number 1 actually said " Thanks Pelor for its powers ..." or the like , I might take it into account when giving XP for either good interpretation or making me smile ;-)Chacal</blockquote>