Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Artoomis" data-source="post: 301240" data-attributes="member: 111">He did a good job of identifying the bad guys, no problem there at all.The only question, really, is in how he challenged them.&nbsp; It should have been very clear that they were being punished for their deeds.As far as outlcassing them, well, he coudln't really know that for sure, could he? He easily could have lost one of those combats, and the player would have been out one paladin - lost to good role playing. He probably should have found some way to bring them to justice before the church, rather than take the law in his own hands.Alternately, he should have run his plans by church officals first, to get their blessings.Be should have to do some sort of penance, to keep him in his place within the church hierarchy.&nbsp; This act pushes teh limits just atad, perhpas, but I'd not call it &quot;evil&quot; - a bit chaotic, perhaps, since he was taking the law into his own hands, but not evil.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Artoomis, post: 301240, member: 111"] He did a good job of identifying the bad guys, no problem there at all. The only question, really, is in how he challenged them. It should have been very clear that they were being punished for their deeds. As far as outlcassing them, well, he coudln't really know that for sure, could he? He easily could have lost one of those combats, and the player would have been out one paladin - lost to good role playing. He probably should have found some way to bring them to justice before the church, rather than take the law in his own hands. Alternately, he should have run his plans by church officals first, to get their blessings. Be should have to do some sort of penance, to keep him in his place within the church hierarchy. This act pushes teh limits just atad, perhpas, but I'd not call it "evil" - a bit chaotic, perhaps, since he was taking the law into his own hands, but not evil. [/QUOTE]

Verification