Your review of Community 3E prestige class ratings?

[Olidammara]

For all the home-brewed prestige classes bopping around the internet, it's inevitable that some you see will be unbalanced or strangely crafted. And if you've got a big pool of classes submitted from many people, a ratings system seems only natural.

What's been your opinion of how "balanced" some of those websites ratings are? At the Community3E.com board, for example, their panel decides whether a prestige class is classic or unbalanced. Are they doing a good job, or are they full of beans?

 

[BiggusGeekus]

Well, let's see. All the ones on my website rock and all the others suck. Wow. That was easy.


... seriously...

Hong has a couple of very good ones on his site. They have nice flavor and are well balanced (though I haven't playtested them). I also like a couple of the ones on Ranger Wicket's site.

I'm sure there are other good ones, but those are the two that leap to mind.

 

[Cloudgatherer]

It's hard to do a good ratings system. The only useful collection and rating of classes that I've seen has come from the netbooks of classes, although I haven't really been looking for others.