Well, I don't think the request for a pdf is an affront to your much appreciated work at compiling the SH or Sep's own writing. I think (and anyone that disagrees or wishes to expand--feel free to jump in) that, in general, a pdf is a more permanent copy than a downloaded thread. It tends to--depending on who does the compiling--look nicer and you can insert the artwork (with permission from the individual artists). You don't need to show all of the extraneous conversation going on within the threads...all the bumps, etc. when there are so many. Plus, .pdfs have the capability of being opened on any operating system...always with the same format. Everything looks as it was originally laid out--no weird formatting. And they also lack the possible virus problem.
Some of us are ready to give up on the thread ever being updated again. But we don't want to forget the thread or the happy happy joy joy it brang to us. So, we'll take the compiled pdf along on our travels beyond the story hour and pull it out one rainy day in the future to remember the goodness or mine it for ideas to assualt our own epic PCs with.
Of course...if there ever was another update...we'd be there, eyes glued and minds focused, as always. But not everyone holds out hope.
But, before I would even begin such a task...I'd want Sep's permission (I'd drop him an email) as well as the artists' permission to include their work. And since it would cut down on the time of production, I'd also ask permission to use your compilation, Cheiromancer.
And if I were to receive a definitive no from any of you...well, I'd just drop it.
If you need a marvelous example of a compiled SH...check out Sagiro's. One of his fans took the SH and crafted the perfect example. Plus, he regularly adds new chapters based on Sagiro's most recent updates.
Again, no offense was meant.
~Fune