Edition Wars: Burying the Hatchet...

[Dandu]

5th edition is the best, and anyone who disagrees is a heathen!

[ame=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=znGBU5oODz8]Daleks: Do Not Blaspheme - YouTube[/ame]

 

[Man in the Funny Hat]

I will bury the hatchet - IN THE SKULL OF YOUR PATHETIC EDITION!

 

[RUMBLETiGER]

The new edition will be fine.... as long as it looks like my favorite edition, plus other stuff, instead of something else.

 

[El Mahdi]

Why can't we all just turn our hatchets towards a much more deserving target...like RIFTS!

 

[Dandu]

Why can't we all just turn our hatchets towards a much more deserving target...like RIFTS!

That would be a FATAL error, as it would mean ignoring The Game That Is Not To Be Named.

 

[El Mahdi]

That would be a FATAL error, as it would mean ignoring The Game That Is Not To Be Named.

Oh, you mean Prince! The RPG...?

Woops...I mean:

 

[xigbar]

We should make a 10 Commandments of D&D, and then impose them upon people who believe otherwise, because they're just misguided, and need guidance.

 

[kitcik]

We should make a 10 Commandments of D&D, and then impose them upon people who believe otherwise, because they're just misguided, and need guidance.

1) Thou shalt not quote rules to the GM, for the GM is the rules.
2) Thou shalt not exalt cheese.
3) Thou shalt not curse the GM, as your character does not know she exists.
4) Thou shalt not play seven days a week; a day is needed for food, rest and bathing.
5) Thou shalt honor thy mother and father - play in the basement with the door closed and leave the last can in the fridge.
6) Thou shalt not violate your alignment.
7) Thou shalt not fudge your die rolls.
8) Thou shalt not use your neighbor's dice.
9) Thou shalt not mark others' books in pen.
10) Thou shalt not whine.

 

[xigbar]

1) Thou shalt not quote rules to the GM, for the GM is the rules.
2) Thou shalt not exalt cheese.
3) Thou shalt not curse the GM, as your character does not know she exists.
4) Thou shalt not play seven days a week; a day is needed for food, rest and bathing.
5) Thou shalt honor thy mother and father - play in the basement with the door closed and leave the last can in the fridge.
6) Thou shalt not violate your alignment.
7) Thou shalt not fudge your die rolls.
8) Thou shalt not use your neighbor's dice.
9) Thou shalt not mark others' books in pen.
10) Thou shalt not whine.

I clicked quote, to say something witty, but, actually, yes for everything but alignment......Now to wait for him to take my bait, and start an arguement!

 

[Alan Shutko]

5th edition is the best, and anyone who disagrees is a heathen!

Yes, it was.

1. OD&D
2. Holmes
3. Moldvay
4. Mentzer
5. Rules Cyclopedia