Plane Sailing
Astral Admin - Mwahahaha!
IcyCool said:The rules on this are vague, and could be ruled either way (which means a house rule).
Although it isn't significant to the discussion in hand, I would like to improve your statement here - if the rules are vague then the DM has to make an adjudication - and that is the kind of thing which we would discuss here in the rules forum. How an existing rule might be interpreted by different people to come up with a version that works for us.
House Rules are more properly considered to be brand new rules, or genuine changes to existing rules - and those would be discussed in (and moved if necessary to) the House Rules forum.
I only mention that because I often see other people throw around 'house rule' as an almost perjorative term against anyone who disagrees with their own adjudication of vague rules You are not doing it in this case of course, it just seemed an apposite opportunity to mention the distinction that moderators will normally use when deciding where a discussion properly lives
Cheers