BelenUmeria said:
The rules have definitely become too complicated. I think it has caused problems. I know that I have experienced a lot of trouble with the rules and how they have changed my game and my group. The game has changed into little more than a tactical wargame. When I have expressed my concerns over how the rules have changed the group, people begin to question why I play DnD, as if a tactical wargame is the only way to play the game.
For me, it seems like 3e has forced a hardline division between gamers. My group has divided along the lines of rules/tactical oriented versus roleplay/story oriented.
No balance exists between the two sides. The rules oriented players dominate the game as they dominate combat. If the roleplay oriented gamers want to compete, then they are forced to delve deep into the rules or get left behind.
Game rulings cannot be made on the fly. If a GM does not have ADVANCED rules knowledge, then the players do not trust him. You are fair if you use the correct rule, while unfair and arbitrary if you do not take the time to find the correct rule.
Rules discussion dominates our game. If not discussing a tactical problem, then people sit and discuss "builds" etc even if the GM is trying to keep the game flowing.
The half of the group that does not have advanced knowledge of the rules usually remains quiet during rules discussion and if someone does speak up or disagree with something, then a long speech takes place detailing why this rule makes things balanced and how it integrates into the game.
There is no middle ground. There is no compromise. You either "build" "optimal" characters or spend combat being ineffective. Once this annoys people with good builds, then they begin making suggestions about how to build the character better. Choices that make sense for the character but are less than optimal are met with disdain.
Now, I truly enjoy the time spent with my friends. I would not trade that experience for anything. Some of them simplely enjoy the rules and work to gain an optimal knowledge and I do not blame them for it.
This is the fault of 3e and how it is PRESENTED. The three core books would not be so bad if every book that followed did not enforce the idea that rules are god. If a book such as Complete Warrior did not contain so many class and feats, and had more balance between crunch and roleplay, then there would be some argument that crunch should not be the focus of the game.
WOTC has made it understood that crunch is the method by which the game is played. They have made it understood that the players should EXPECT a game of strict rules that leave the GM little more than a mediator or servant. Their focus is on players and what they can continually give players to sell books. Player empowerment, GM restriction.
Are the rules too complicated? Hell YES.
Barrier to entry? Yes
Why? Too many rules and how the heck can a group of kids want to learn the game since not one of them would want to GM for the game.
Motto: Third Edition, everyone wants to play, no one wants to GM.
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetuer adipiscing elit. Fusce iaculis tempor neque. Duis ac justo vel risus lobortis elementum. Ut vulputate neque sed eros. Nulla sit amet elit. Praesent et elit. Sed eu orci. In vehicula lacus eget tellus. Maecenas at felis quis neque vestibulum bibendum. Nunc vitae nisl at lorem adipiscing luctus. Aliquam erat volutpat. Donec pellentesque. In nulla tortor, pellentesque a, cursus eget, ultricies a, tortor.
Proin ligula wisi, porta in, aliquam at, sollicitudin nec, est. Nulla egestas, diam eget ultricies mollis, ante orci tincidunt pede, sed eleifend ante arcu id quam. Maecenas a mauris a ipsum accumsan rhoncus. Cras eget urna. Nulla id lacus quis ante fermentum varius. Ut scelerisque ipsum eu nibh. Duis commodo. Vivamus vulputate eros sit amet enim. Mauris convallis. Pellentesque mauris neque, interdum eget, ullamcorper quis, sagittis a, libero.
Aenean at lorem lacinia metus vestibulum pharetra. Nulla bibendum odio sed ipsum. Ut neque ligula, vestibulum non, accumsan sit amet, vulputate quis, urna. Aenean nec lorem. Cum sociis natoque penatibus et magnis dis parturient montes, nascetur ridiculus mus. Cras nibh. Curabitur sollicitudin. Cras laoreet, lorem et bibendum mollis, mi dolor varius nisl, sit amet scelerisque nisl dui at mauris. Curabitur pellentesque. Ut feugiat arcu eu ligula. Donec nibh magna, volutpat nec, imperdiet nec, viverra congue, lorem. Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetuer adipiscing elit. Fusce vestibulum vulputate sem. Maecenas id augue eget est pharetra viverra. Nam dapibus mollis enim. Integer viverra sapien ac mi. Cras at urna quis ligula nonummy fringilla. Nullam odio est, dictum et, aliquam sed, imperdiet eget, nibh. Vestibulum ante ipsum primis in faucibus orci luctus et ultrices posuere cubilia Curae;
Sed sit amet dolor. In ultricies. Nullam quis mi quis diam varius ultricies. Mauris ac ante id lacus posuere iaculis. Aliquam et turpis in ipsum rutrum ornare. Vestibulum in magna. Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetuer adipiscing elit. In vel dolor. Maecenas pede wisi, auctor aliquet, aliquam in, fermentum quis, dui. Vestibulum ante ipsum primis in faucibus orci luctus et ultrices posuere cubilia Curae; In at sem sed leo tincidunt egestas. Nam fringilla nibh eget wisi. Nulla facilisi. Aenean mattis, elit ac bibendum dictum, dolor arcu laoreet risus, in consequat eros wisi ac ligula. Donec sit amet libero. Sed sit amet dolor. Cras suscipit, sapien a scelerisque cursus, nibh wisi varius magna, in aliquet eros nibh sed lorem. Quisque aliquet tempus est.
Standard rant reply included.