Alzrius
The EN World kitten
A quick update with a comparison between the Sunless Citadel adventure path and Dark Sun adventures, along with a note from Riggs. As always, credit goes to @darjr for posting these:
It is with some hesitation that I offer this chart comparing Dark Sun adventure sales in 1992 to Sunless Citadel AP sales in 2001. I have chosen those years because they are the first full year of release for the respective brands, and bluntly, they are years I have sales data for.
This comparison might be apples and oranges
This comparison might be too little data, over too short a period of time.
But! I do think it has some use. Dark Sun had five adventures for sale by the end of 1992. Sunless Citadel had six. But the SC AP sold 43% better than Dark Sun.
If you're looking for data to prove 3rd edition turned D&D around, this might be a piece of it.
Next, I'll release sales data for other adventures up for sale in 2001, such as Return to the Temple of Elemental Evil.
Have you read my book? Link below.
Raw sales data also below.
-Ben