Alright, I'm new to PbP, but not to D&D. However, I love the classic-run D&D games! In other words, I'm looking for a game where everyone starts at first level, we get a good mix of urban, wilderness, and dungeon-crawl adventures, a reasonable point-buy system is used (no 52 point buy or 15 point buy), and that's about all I really want. Campaign worlds don't really matter (though I usually play in generic or homebrew worlds, so if someone runs a Forgotten Realms or Eberron campaign, please give me a quick rundown of relevant info and politics, and maybe a campy little world map), and I'm willing to play with only Core rules, but I would prefer a little more freedom concerning that (I enjoy using the Complete series). Alignment doesn't matter, I have more than my fair share of both Good, Neutral, and Evil characters.
Above all else, though... I'm looking for a good, long game. Play from first level to Epic levels, take down CR 20 or higher monsters, etc. I want a LOT of time for character development and good role-playing! A full-sized campaign would be great.
Sorry if I seem too picky, but this is just the kind of game I've always wanted to play, but my current DM doesn't like too much.