Seems we have more wanting or willing to spend the night -- not that it matters too terribly much, since, unless you do something, it will be uneventful.
You avail yourselves of the old farmer's hospitality. He regales you with stories through the rest of the day, and fills your stomaches with simple farm-food that evening, washed down with water, milk, and moonshine (if you like). He is very happy to have is barn back, and glad that his cow Leslie is unhurt. The old man cooks up some lizard meat, but the only ones willing to try the stuff are Titus and Gertrude, who go at it with relish. He offers you a reward, but has nothing but some food, which he insists you take.
You all gain 5 days of trail rations.
You don't take him up on his offer of spending the night in the blood-splattered barn, but the main room of his house, once the table is moved aside, is quite large enough for you to all be comfortable and warm. In the morning, he sends you off refreshed and fully healed, ready to face the next day and whatever the road might bring.