[sblock=OOC]First of all, let me state that I very much appreciate playing with a group where such attention to detail is paid: I have played in groups who wouldn't think twice about a blatant alignment subversion. So thank you; I honestly do appreciate you pointing out your qualm.
That said, Etain is bluffing. I did, in fact, make a Bluff skill check above. Etain would not kill an unarmed captive, even if said thug had previously been attacking her. However, she has no problem letting the thug think she's willing to kill him; I see this as in accordance with the Chaotic half of her alignment. If our GM disagrees, of course, I will rescind my comment.[/sblock]