William Ronald
Explorer
Mark CMG said:It did appear to be a toughie.
For my part, today, I helped facilitate the event as it was run at Games Plus. William Ronald DM'd one table and had his players on the ropes most of the game. (picture)
The event came very close to a total party kill at times, but my players used their abilities well and had some good luck. (The players used their wits, and expended a lot of resources. Even with that a few different dice rolls could have easily lead to a total party kill -- as some of the PCs went down to negative hit points.)
I do agree that the official adventure was a bit tough, as there were several actions that the PCs could have taken that would put them in deadly peril. They avoided one encounter that would have summoned a lot of enemies quickly, even though their noise did alert some of the other inhabitants of the Fane of Lolth.
I found the event puzzling in some ways. First, if it was meant to draw in new players, then perhaps an adventure for 1st level characters might have been more appropriate. Secondly, I thought some of the design choices were a little puzzling. Still, I had fun running the adventure.