We used a counter from the Fiery Dragon Summoned Creatures Counter Collection 5 last night for a Huge Water Elemental, which is nice enough but a mini is always a bit better for my gang, particularly when we're using minis for other things.
Um, don't you two have access to Peter. Make it happen already.
There is no such thing as a water elemental in D&D anymore, so i doubt they'll be making a miniature for it.