D&D 5E MTG Color Identity System for D&D characters (Ravnica, Theros, etc)

[Morrus]

I'm not so sure about the waste of time bit (in general, not specific to you).

Don't worry. It's just me parodying the way Envisioner talks to people about their creative content. I didn't even read the post! At least I didn't call him cringey and annoying.

 

[Envisioner]

Don't worry. It's just me parodying the way Envisioner talks to people about their creative content. I didn't even read the post! At least I didn't call him cringey and annoying.

Not all creative content; just yours so far. (Also I liked you better as a dog )

 

[cbwjm]

If using the colour wheel to determine alignment, I wouldn't even bother using the DnD system. Instead I'd use the various descriptors in the colour wheel to define the basic personality. If you decide your high intelligence character focuses technology (a blue trait) but acts impulsively (a red trait) creating dangerous artifacts that run wild then you've got yourself a red/blue alignment and probably get on well in the Izzet guild. Since nothing interacts with alignment anyway, you probably don't even need to mention the colours, just look at them for inspiration for your basic PCs characteristics.

 

[JiffyPopTart]

Intrigued by the concept....but wouldn't it be simpler to let the player self select however many Mana symbols you want to have attached to their character rather than a complex assignment system?

 

[Raduin711]

I think this article might be helpful:

Pie Fights | MAGIC: THE GATHERING

Mark breaks down the conflicts that exist within the color wheel and what makes them interesting.

magic.wizards.com

For your personality questions, they should probably be framed thus:

Q1: Good of the Group vs. Good of the Individual
vs.
Q2: Head vs. Heart
vs.
Q3: Free Will vs. Destiny
vs.
Q4: Freedom vs. Security
vs.
Q5: Nature vs. Nurture
vs.

 

[Envisioner]

Now that was cringey and annoying. Dude, you're not cute. You border on offensive, and step over that line frequently.

Somebody apparently has difficulty taking criticism. It's not "offensive" to tell a car manufacturer that their car is poorly-made. I'm not trying to hurt your feelings, I just expressed my opinion that your product was not for me, and you appear to have taken it way too personally.