"This has all happened before, and this will all happen again."
Well, lets just hope it's not a Prequel set during the First Cylon War. Or something beyond horrible like...sigh....a Kidz Re-imaging about a group of cool, misfit, ''runaway", orphan teens living on the Glattatica during the 2003 re boot. And you could have cool scenes like the cool kids are rapping and dancing to a beat in the hallway, and Adama walks by to growl "no dancing on my ship!"
At the most basic Battlestar Galactica HAS to be, ahem, "Fleeing from the Cylon tyranny, the last Battlestar, Galactica leads a rag-tag fugitive fleet on a lonely quest…a shining planet known as Earth.” Really, the genre don't not really have room for "other" things. Like you can't do a Caprica Cops show, or 12 Colonies CSI, or Cylon Full House.
BUT......well, they COULD do it all again. Set in the same universe as the 2003 one.....but now like 200,000 years in the future with yet ANOTHER 12 colonies and yet ANOTHER AI is a crapshoot revolution.......but, you know with a different spin. And....heck....you could have any of the 'old' actors come back as new characters...or even as their original characters if they are cylons or "angels".