• NOW LIVE! Into the Woods--new character species, eerie monsters, and haunting villains to populate the woodlands of your D&D games.

The Book of Boba Fett (spoilers)

I don't know if it's true, but folks on Twitter claimed that Luke's voice wasn't genuine Mark Hamill, but rather an AI-generated voice trained on audio books Hamill had read. That would explain the uncanny (as in "uncanny valley") acting.
I feel a disturbance in the Force, as though thousands of voice actors had suddenly cried out in anguish, and been suddenly silenced.

But more seriously, I find that a little unlikely - it's something that might be done to recapture the voice of a deceased actor, if the technology is there, but Mark Hamill is still around, and still perfectly willing to work on Star Wars projects.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

At times, Filoni has a good feel for the SW universe, and other times, he doesn't have a good feel for storytelling/pacing.
I chalk it up to him loving Star Wars a bit too much for someone whose job is to create more of it. He occasionally forgets you need to do more than put these characters onscreen (but he's usually good - I really enjoyed his use of Thrawn in Rebels).

That said, I'm seeing a lot of really positive reactions to the last episode. It clearly worked for some people.
 

so we have 2 pathways ahead-one Grogu goes with the mandalorian and there is no canon rewritten. Or he stays and the part where Kylo is the first student is rewritten (he says in one of the movies hes the first of Lukes students).
That cat is out of the bag already. Whether he stays or goes, as soon as Luke started training him he became Luke's first student. All that remains to be seen is whether he dies by Kylo's hand or not.
Do we think that we are possibly getting a certain Dark sun leader?
My vote is for Borys of Ur Draxa
 
Last edited:

I don't know if it's true, but folks on Twitter claimed that Luke's voice wasn't genuine Mark Hamill, but rather an AI-generated voice trained on audio books Hamill had read. That would explain the uncanny (as in "uncanny valley") acting.

No, he recorded the lines and then they used the tech to "de-age" his voice, so it sounded like Mark would have when in his 20's. they did the same in the Mandalorian episode and I think they explained it in the Making of Mando season 2 episode.
 

(he says in one of the movies hes the first of Lukes students).

Pretty sure that he means he is the first student at the new Academy/Temple, not first student ever. And wouldn't Luke's attempts to train Leia make her his first student ever? Or is that purely non-canon now?

Besides, there is the canon comic book about those early years and the destruction of the temple by Kylo, that may say more on that, but I have not read it. Ben Solo is about 4-5 years old as the Academy is being built, so him being the first student after it is ready makes sense still. Also, the Legends date for it being finished and ready for students is 11 ABY, or about two years from the start of construction in episode 6, if they use the same year for canon.
 

I think the cgi may be partly to blame. CGI Luke looks pretty good but they seem to take things really slow when he’s talking and interacting, I’m guessing to make it easy for the cgi.
Could be. Mando and Grogu work so well thanks, in large part, to Pascal's acting.
 

No, he recorded the lines and then they used the tech to "de-age" his voice, so it sounded like Mark would have when in his 20's. they did the same in the Mandalorian episode and I think they explained it in the Making of Mando season 2 episode.
That makes sense. It does both sound like Mark and not like Mark, so this may explain it.
 

No, he recorded the lines and then they used the tech to "de-age" his voice, so it sounded like Mark would have when in his 20's. they did the same in the Mandalorian episode and I think they explained it in the Making of Mando season 2 episode.
That makes more sense, and still explains why it doesn't quite work.
 

Pretty sure that he means he is the first student at the new Academy/Temple, not first student ever. And wouldn't Luke's attempts to train Leia make her his first student ever? Or is that purely non-canon now?

Besides, there is the canon comic book about those early years and the destruction of the temple by Kylo, that may say more on that, but I have not read it. Ben Solo is about 4-5 years old as the Academy is being built, so him being the first student after it is ready makes sense still. Also, the Legends date for it being finished and ready for students is 11 ABY, or about two years from the start of construction in episode 6, if they use the same year for canon.
It could also be perspective. If Baby Yoda has come and gone before Kylo ever gets there, he might believe that he was the first student and just be incorrect.
 

It's not that everybody would be expected to have seen them in person, but there are small groups on Earth that everybody is pretty much aware of even if they don't know the details. Famous football teams, for example. Hollywood actors. The SAS. The Mafia. And historical groups like the Templars, Spartans, etc. are remembered hundreds of years later. It does seem weird that in an advanced industrial galaxy with instantaneous comms that people wouldn't know of the magic lightsaber wielding space wizard galactic peacekeepers. If you lived in the Empire, you'd know what a jedi is (or was). You probably remember them from when you were a teenager, and if not your parents do.
Remember some stories, sure. But in 20 years, the context of those stories could have significantly changed under propaganda pressure from the Empire. Consider the idea that a xenophobic government, in the aftermath of a war largely against aliens where many people are grappling with tremendous amounts of economic difficulty, might use those factors to come to power, seize the media, order a dictatorially-run and oversized military around to suppress dissent, and manipulate the public. The Nazis turned the German public and the fringe anti-Semitism there into a genocide machine behind a monomaniacal cult of personality in less time.
Granted, there's a vast difference in scale - but then understanding the immensity of the Republic/Empire/New Republic and space in general has never been the series's strong point.
 

Into the Woods

Remove ads

Top