1QD's latest activity

Yes, but this thread isn't dedicated just to D&D. If you prefer, you can adjust my statement to "Everything is not about D&D, you...

If I mis-read then I apologize.

All true. Prior to mass manufacture people at least knew how to fix things, if not make them from scratch. I guess the claim I'm...

Literally the worst take on this I can think of. No where near the mark.

It would probably turn on how common/easy it is to do enchantment, but really, until you do the magical equivelent of mass manufacture...

I am taking by your response, you have a heavy DnD background?

Thieves and Fighters are distinct enough to warrant separate classes. Take away the skills and Backstab (the class's defining features)...

Not what is logical... I would add that in context. So in my world , it is based off of reality, but what if dragons and magic were...

This was questioned in another thread. You could say the thing about any class. You don't need a paladin, you only need a cleric. You...

I like thieves, but because they have a niche: urban stealth. This is often expanded to criminal contacts and techniques. They are not...

Given the amount of TTRPG's that don't have thieves, I'd say we don't need them. Even DnD relegated thieves to a sub-class.

Even when Combat and Magic are also Skill best there are often have extra steps like using mana points or spell slots, and of course...

...

Okay. I'm not inclined to argue it further in this thread, since we are already way off topic.

You don't have to call it "thief" or "rogue" (to use the modern parlance), but in order to have a reasonable simulation of a world...