AlViking's latest activity

It seems exactly like that kind of case to me? I get the cook wasn't introduced at the same moment the hard move occurs, but making the...

Sure, but there's those differing expectations rearing their ugly head again.

In that it would be better without them. I would rather have the cool original species from the demo than generic WotC stuff shoehorned...

If the cook is only there because of the lockpick roll, yes. Improv =/= quantum. Existing and not existing until after a die is rolled...

Ideally their notes would have spelled it out beforehand, saying something like: Kitchen. Day: 2 cooks and 1 dishwasher. Night: 1-in-6...

They are logical consequences to failure that you've implemented because you're playing a style of game where something must happen...

I appreciate the explanation. Your definition of fail forward seems to be different from what other people stated which became...

How does your refutation of my statement actually refute it? Your goal is to bash on / aggressively analyze traditional play. And that's...

The survey they have up for the 2024 announcement asks what people want to see as post game content and one option is “adventures in the...

Except it's still not stakeless. Simply allowing Jane to break into the warehouse without a roll makes a pile of assumptions I'm not...

My bolding. Also for reference the heading for the list you quoted: "Every time it’s your turn in the conversation to tell the hunters...

It is if it's the eldritch monstrosity trying to open the lock. ;)

You're confused. Correlation does not equal causation. The cook being there)or not) isn't connected to picking a lock Yep. You are...

And yet folks keep trying to apply techniques designed for Narrativist systems to traditional games, and wondering why fans of those...

Yet people regularly don't qualify the context so we're left to guess. The default in that case is to assume D&D. Just like if I were in...