AlViking's latest activity

"I jump the gap", "I climb the tower", "I kill the goblin" is all action declarations according to 2. None of them makes the thing...

You just need to find some runes and hope they indicate an exit ;)

Post 20,000! Let’s give it up for post 20,000! Wooo!

I see no reason to believe that. People use Maps for homebrew and custom maps as well, it wouldn't make any business sense for them to...

You can always import images, make your own maps and so on. So if someone has access to the map they can download the jpeg, give it to...

It has been my experience that a DM that figuratively summons pixies to explain falling damage, and does that on a whim, will be lacking...

I like this example. With a trapdoor, you already know its function. Your roll is to utilise its function. With the runes, you do not...

Truth. You can pick your friends. You can pick your nose. You can't pick your friend's noses. :)

No it doesn't. Yep. You CAN do those things. Not will. And that's the definition of obedient, not authority. You see, if someone...

That's not what I said. The context of what I said was that it MUST fit within both what the mechanics tell us AND the prior narrative...

An exit makes sense in that it may have been used in construction of the dungeon or some other purpose. Perhaps it was used as an exit...

Better explanation than mine. If the player is spending meta-game points* to get what they want with associated risks, that's not a...

I think the issue here is the following: Either it was a move that was done fully according to the rules of the game with approperiate...

In all fairness, taken at face value I have to agree with this. Which means my issue isn't with what the player did in this case, it's...

Again, you're missing the point and I doubt you will ever accept what I say at face value. So let me try a slightly different...