AlViking's latest activity

I assume that unless specified otherwise it's D&D as published by WotC. I'm well aware that you consider many games D&D that I, and most...

By martials I meant people that use weapons. You know, the ones affected by the proposed rules.

Isn't using different weapons depending on circumstances part of the logic behind weapon mastery? Because that to me feels like a...

I was countering the idea that item breaking was super common in older editions thats being tied to other opinions of having it happen...

If you want to start up a thread about how to apply "verisimilitude" to all classes go ahead. Except is there is no verisimilitude when...

I don't remember ever using that rule, but then the rest of my arguments remain. Where are the penalties for the characters that don't...

A fighter would likely look something like the following if the rule was used

Accusing people of "getting worked up" about a topic is dismissive of them expressing their opinion and is not constructive in any way.

Depends on the DM. If magic weapons don't break then the rule is pointless once the characters affected get magic weapons.

Imagine making it difficult to find spell components or spell components getting ruined if the character fails a save or gets wet...

I assume we're talking D&D on a D&D forum and the game has no encumbrance rules. I care about verisimilitude to a certain degree but...

Sorry you don't like a counter opinion. Let's be honest, whenever these restrictive mechanics are proposed they are always aimed at...

Do you also have casters constantly scrounging for spell components? Make that monk risk bruising their knuckles or that cleric's god...

Is it really helpful to accuse people of "getting worked up" when they have an opinion you disagree with? This is a rule I've...