Andvari's latest activity

  • Andvari
    Andvari reacted to Bill Zebub's post in the thread Why I Hate Skills with Like Like.
    Yeah somehow I wasn't parsing what you expressed perfectly clearly. :-/ The play loop in those examples don't meet my criteria, but I...
  • Andvari
    Andvari reacted to Micah Sweet's post in the thread Why I Hate Skills with Like Like.
    That is exactly what I had in mind.
  • Andvari
    Andvari reacted to CreamCloud0's post in the thread Why I Hate Skills with Haha Haha.
    OotS always comes through :LOL:
  • Andvari
    Andvari reacted to Bill Zebub's post in the thread Why I Hate Skills with Like Like.
    Ah, right. I had to go back to see what Micah had written, and realize I must have somehow mis-read it the first time. That all makes...
  • Andvari
    For electronic I prefer a .txt file with all text in one single line, long line. For print I prefer braille (in Klingon, obviously).
  • Andvari
    Andvari reacted to VHawkwinter's post in the thread Why I Hate Skills with Like Like.
    Absolutely. But if you show them they rolled a 2, they'll know there's a very good chance they're missing important information.
  • Andvari
    Andvari replied to the thread Why I Hate Skills.
    In Pathfinder 2E, for example, if you use Recall Knowledge in a combat to learn something about a monster and critically fail. You learn...
  • Andvari
    Andvari reacted to Micah Sweet's post in the thread Why I Hate Skills with Like Like.
    The roll does follow. It just isn't necessarily rolled by the player if they shouldn't have that information.
  • Andvari
    Justified text can look great (see the D&D 3rd edition books as an example), but it can be a pain to work with and isn't suitable in...
  • Andvari
    Andvari reacted to Bill Zebub's post in the thread Why I Hate Skills with Like Like.
    Wow. That’s…well, in line with stereotypes about gamers. But beyond the presumption, it also shows a gross misunderstanding of my...
  • Andvari
    Andvari replied to the thread Why I Hate Skills.
    It's Castles & Crusades that has the SIEGE engine. The way it works is that when you make an attribute (ability score) check, you roll...
  • Andvari
    Andvari reacted to Bill Zebub's post in the thread Why I Hate Skills with Like Like.
    .... And do you think this example undermines the argument? Because, sure, if in D&D the d20 was replaced by a d4 I also think the...
  • Andvari
    Now you can never unsee it. *Edit, also probably why you won't see a Moana 3... In traditional Māori mythology, the demigod Māui...
  • Andvari
    Andvari replied to the thread Why I Hate Skills.
    I know some use saving throws in B/X and BECMI D&D as resolution mechanics. For example, if you try something dexterous or agile, you...
  • Andvari
    Andvari reacted to pemerton's post in the thread Why I Hate Skills with Like Like.
    These seem to be pretty similar ideas. A world where events occur with the regularity of a metronome is just as "meta" as the OotS...
Top