AnotherGuy's latest activity

Just to clarify - @clearstream is stating that it is impossible to incapacitate minions since any damage "destroys" them. Therefore...

I agree that the attempt to knock out should be declared in advance. We got rid of that asinine portion of the rule the first time we...

I still maintain, however, that it's possible to get the fanbase to settle for two official versions: very broadly a 1-2e-like (more...

I tend to think of minions as the 3.5e templates

We had the conversation before actually. It was an experiment. Our GM had heard that this style of boss monster works well. It did not...

I was very active on the Paizo forums for the decade or so I played Pathfinder. What I saw a lot of was players wanting to tell their DM...

I would like to add that it seems that people are conflating two different concerns into NPCs should be built like PCs, and its causing...

3e did it too. I didn’t like the result then either. Return on investment - pages in a core book and time - isn’t worth it. IMHO...

It seems like what some folks want is a set of tables or formulae to calculate what the CR of creature should be based on its abilities...

I liked this post and quoted it for truth. I wish I could praise it more.

Star Trek: West Wing you say. So WWE in space?

Not just the mechanics but the entire 4e ethos was ignored because.......stormtroopers or something.

You did. The only way that destroyed precludes unconcious is if targets cannot be killed. Because anything that can be killed can be...

I feel like RPGs are basically synonymous with asinine layouting and even more asinine wording, and while they should be rightfully...

How this thread feels as someone that never played 4E (I'm not really having a go at anyone, just amazed at the lack of Minion gifs...