log in or register to remove this ad

 

Recent content by ardoughter

  1. ardoughter

    General Baldur's Gate 3 Early Access

    Your feed back here will not be seen by Larian and has zero possibility of being taken on board and resulting in a change in the game. On Larian's forums or on the Steam discussion boards(If you bought the game through Steam) there is a very good chance of Larian becoming aware of your issues...
  2. ardoughter

    General Baldur's Gate 3 Early Access

    Have you sent this feed back to Larian?
  3. ardoughter

    Allegory VS Interpretation

    As someone that spend 10 years caring for a dementia patient, the idea of putting leash on them, strikes me as appalling. Also, counter productive as it would most like make them distressed and violent, followed by distress on the part of the person on the other end of the leash as they receive...
  4. ardoughter

    5E What changes or retcons would you approve in a reboot?

    I am not sure if D&D setting really need reboots in any real sense. Rebooting a setting makes sense where the consumers of setting are consumers of an increasing complex lore. At that time sales of new stories in the setting are being inhibited by the amount of back story needed to understand...
  5. ardoughter

    General Dragonlance's Margaret Weis & Tracy Hickman Are Suing WotC for Breach of Contract

    I accept that, that what you are saying is a possibility and very likely to be what WoTC will claim, if this goes to court. However, someone at Hasbro or WoTC looked at Dragonlance in general, and decided that Goldmoon is a whitewashed Native American or there was some other issue in...
  6. ardoughter

    D&D doesn't need birds

    Birds are particularly to bards, my brother took out a parrot with an electric guitar and a Marshal Stack.
  7. ardoughter

    General Dragonlance's Margaret Weis & Tracy Hickman Are Suing WotC for Breach of Contract

    I just want point out that all we know of this case is Weis & Hickman's deposition to the court and they claim to be willing to take editorial direction and make any and all re-writes necessary to get the books published but that WoTC is refusing to give such editorial direction, and WoTC are...
  8. ardoughter

    5E Jeremy Crawford Discusses Details on Custom Origins

    Thanks for the response, I originally responded because I was confused by your previous post. i do agree that there has been a strong trend toward casual playstyles over the years. I see that as partly inevitable, there are so many competing time sinking hobbies. The same trend is observable in...
  9. ardoughter

    5E Jeremy Crawford Discusses Details on Custom Origins

    I am not quite sure what you mean by this. If the rule is optional and not in the PHB then unless one is aware of the new rule or bought the supplement then one can continue as if this new rule does not exist. In fact one could be completely unaware of it. Even if one is aware of the new rules...
  10. ardoughter

    5E Jeremy Crawford Discusses Details on Custom Origins

    That is because they are not re-writing the PHB.
  11. ardoughter

    5E Jeremy Crawford Discusses Details on Custom Origins

    Well speaking for myself, First off, I am not actually bothered one way or another about fixed or free floating stat bonuses but. Despite being involved in D&D for near 40 years and on ENWorld before 3.5 was a thing but after 3.0 was a thing, I do not have a lot of DM experience. Mostly because...
  12. ardoughter

    General Dragonlance's Margaret Weis & Tracy Hickman Are Suing WotC for Breach of Contract

    On this case, I disagree with your take. Weis and Hickman's case, as I understand it that WoTC breached their licence agreement by interfering in the relationships between Wei and Hickman and their publisher and acted in bad faith by refusing to specify what changes would make the books...
  13. ardoughter

    General "Hot" take: Aesthetically-pleasing rules are highly overvalued

    I think that the natural language approach was also informed by "giving the DM Authority" Ultimately the DM is going to have issue rulings in any case even where keywords and careful definitions are used. There used to be a very strong push to the notion that the Rules as Written was the...
  14. ardoughter

    General Dragonlance's Margaret Weis & Tracy Hickman Are Suing WotC for Breach of Contract

    I agree it is just a lawsuit and I really expect it to be settled out of court. I watched the Hoeg Law video analysis of the suit I referenced up thread and it appears that the change of editors kicks off the friction but I suspect that some high up the food chain decided at some point to simply...
Top