Recent content by Argyle King

  1. Argyle King

    Goodman Games: Our Efforts Have Been Mischaracterized

    So far, it seems that around 1500 people are willing to pay for the product and upcoming projects still seem fine. I think it helps that Goodman Games is doing what they said they would do (e.g. limiting the print run; limiting the pdfs) to ensure that JG does not financially benefit. Post...
  2. Argyle King

    Goodman Games: Our Efforts Have Been Mischaracterized

    Invincible Overlord seems to be doing pretty well on Backerkit. I had thought that some of the negative buzz might slow the project down, but it instead appears to be selling faster than I thought it would. Overall, Goodman Games still seems to be going strong. Castle Whiterock now has over...
  3. Argyle King

    AD&D/OSRIC: How did initiative work?

    I appreciate the active discourse and response. My knowledge of AD&D is very limited. I recently had the good fortune to be given some old modules and supplements. Around the same time, I became more aware of OSRIC. I imagine that surprised and initiative might not be too terrible once I got...
  4. Argyle King

    AD&D/OSRIC: How did initiative work?

    At first, I thought "doesn't seem so bad." Then, I realized that I was on page 2 of 20.
  5. Argyle King

    AD&D/OSRIC: How did initiative work?

    I've read through some of the information about OSRIC on Backerkit. The following descriptions stood out to me: "...2. Adding Encounter Distance to the combat sequence, per AD&D rules. Not precisely the same method -- the AD&D rules for encounter distance and especially how they interact with...
  6. Argyle King

    Worlds of Design: Battle Maneuvers

    Something that is often overlooked is command & control. Being able to communicate and coordinate attacks via Sending Stones (or something similar) can open up a lot of tactical options. Even without magic, a lot of simple things like colored smoke or a trumpet can be used to communicate with...
  7. Argyle King

    Worlds of Design: Battle Maneuvers

    From the DM side of things, a combination of #3 and #5 work well against over-eager PCs. Give up the center to a charging PC and lead them into double envelopment. Whether or not the game uses Facing Rules has some influence on how effective such tactics may be, but being surrounded and...
  8. Argyle King

    Judges Guild Makes Statement About Goodman Controversy [Updated]

    If I misunderstood or misattributed your specific statement, then I apologize that I did so.
  9. Argyle King

    Judges Guild Makes Statement About Goodman Controversy [Updated]

    I would agree that not believing Goodman is not equivalent to believing Bledsaw. However, using the Bledsaw statement as the basis upon which to judge that Goodman should not be believed (or that Goodman should be believed less) indicates that value is being placed upon Bledsaw's statement. I...
  10. Argyle King

    Judges Guild Makes Statement About Goodman Controversy [Updated]

    Could be different parts of the contract. Hard to say without seeing the actual contract.
  11. Argyle King

    Judges Guild Makes Statement About Goodman Controversy [Updated]

    See my above post. I definitely agree that it is a questionable decision to sign something of that nature. Maybe there is some morally-questionable reason on the part of Goodman. Factually, I cannot say 100% whether there is or not. However, I can verify the existence of one-sided NDAs...
  12. Argyle King

    Judges Guild Makes Statement About Goodman Controversy [Updated]

    Below will be some examples. The examples are just from this thread; I can sift through the other threads if you honestly want me to do so, but that will take some time. Note that, in most cases, I have not directly quoted the posters because I do not want to be bated into some accusation that...
  13. Argyle King

    Judges Guild Makes Statement About Goodman Controversy [Updated]

    That's a lot of buzzwords, but none of them apply to me. There are people who have listed all the negatives about Bledsaw but then also have expressed that he should be believed over other conflicting statements. At no point have I shown a lack of courage -even when you were trying to bate me...
  14. Argyle King

    Judges Guild Makes Statement About Goodman Controversy [Updated]

    Valid points and an understandable point of view. What's odd to me is that the community has expressed that Bledsaw is a crooked businessman who has jipped people out of money while also engaging in a glutinous buffet of bigotry, but now he is also held up as an avatar of honesty who should be...
  15. Argyle King

    Judges Guild Makes Statement About Goodman Controversy [Updated]

    I can agree that signing such an agreement may have been a poor decision. On the other hand, I do not think it is a unique thing that someone signs or agrees to something without taking the time to fully understand it.
Top