Recent content by Captain Thark

When I see #3, I think of the best parts of D&D. If I was a thirteen year old looking at book covers I would pick the third over the others. And, like it or not, that's who we want playing, so the hobby can keep going. It also hearkens back to older editions so the nostalgia factor is good...

I'd say both. Every level the PC gets to choose whether they get half their hit die or roll. Leave it up to the player.

I'm intrigued by the mention of 'Minion Rules'.