cbwjm's latest activity

No, you're correct about 5e (unless they removed this option in 2024). Identify is the quick way of determining magical properties...

I'm fine with short campaigns, I ran one during the lockdowns all those years ago. At least I'd probably consider it one. It was a bunch...

Just a note that you can change hit points from fixed to manual, otherwise (from memory) using long rests and resetting hit points...

It warms my soul that people are arguing about the rules for hide and seek. 😂

4e's rules weren't perfect, but they might be one of the best in the history of the game. You can make a Stealth check at the end of...

It might be better to go back to 4e and see if those rules can easily be ported into 5e.

The 4e rules are very good imo. Covers all the normal stuff such as: 1) What happens if there are multiple people? 2) What happens if I...

Thankfully I don't, I thought you might since you mentioned that you'd just have to have the same argument at the table if your players...

Has DnD ever had good hide rules? I suspect the 2024 rules are just keeping with tradition.

Let's not go to crazy levels, dozens might be more accurate than thousands :ROFLMAO: I find it is useful when I have a rules inquiry to...

Depends how argumentative your players are. I think with my group I can get away with saying, I've discussed this with others online and...

I like arguing about rules on forums so that I don't have to argue about them at the table.

Don't the rules say exactly that, though? "The Dungeon Master decides when circumstances are appropriate for hiding," and, per the...

In that situation, I didn't allow rogues (or anyone who tries to stealth) to become hidden again, once they know that you're behind that...