Celebrim's latest activity

  • Celebrim
    Celebrim replied to the thread Should PCs Be Exceptional?.
    Batman's biggest superpower is he was born wealthy, and not just comfortable but preeminently wealthy. That and he apparently has an 18...
  • Celebrim
    Celebrim reacted to Campbell's post in the thread Should PCs Be Exceptional? with Like Like.
    Rand al'Thor and Luke Skywalker are just about the worst zero to hero examples one could come up with. They are good at just about...
  • Celebrim
    Celebrim replied to the thread Should PCs Be Exceptional?.
    Well, one answer might be that ability scores don't obey a bell curve in the general population. If there were a general lack of...
  • Celebrim
    Celebrim reacted to Staffan's post in the thread Should PCs Be Exceptional? with Like Like.
    This I would tend to agree with, albeit it varies a bit depending on the campaign/game. But I generally want highly competent...
  • Celebrim
    Celebrim reacted to payn's post in the thread The Entire TTRPG Hobby Post-Mortem with Like Like.
    It was a pleasure meeting you, sir. Maybe after some time off your battery will recharge or maybe this hobby just ran its course for...
  • Celebrim
    Celebrim reacted to Retreater's post in the thread The Entire TTRPG Hobby Post-Mortem with Sad Sad.
    For the last several years, I have been analyzing the successes and failures of each of my campaigns as they ended in a series of...
  • Celebrim
    Celebrim reacted to Micah Sweet's post in the thread Should PCs Be Exceptional? with Like Like.
    It's a shame that PC exceptionalism only has those two poles and nothing in between.
  • Celebrim
    Celebrim replied to the thread Should PCs Be Exceptional?.
    But that's only because Rand doesn't know he can cast "burning hands". The first time Rand crosses blade with in a Heronmark, he levels...
  • Celebrim
    Celebrim replied to the thread Should PCs Be Exceptional?.
    Rand al'Thor was NEVER normal. Rand just thought he was normal. Rand's story arc is about figuring out just how not normal in any...
  • Celebrim
    Celebrim replied to the thread Should PCs Be Exceptional?.
    I think there is a difference between "exceptional in potential" and "exceptional in competency/capability", and I think it is important...
  • Celebrim
    Celebrim reacted to Reynard's post in the thread Should PCs Be Exceptional? with Like Like.
    That certainly isn't true for Aragorn, and questionable for the Shadow at the start of his "PCness."
  • Celebrim
    Celebrim reacted to Reynard's post in the thread Should PCs Be Exceptional? with Like Like.
    I feel like there is an excluded middle here. Exceptional does not necessarily mean Superman level. The Shadow is exceptional. So is...
  • Celebrim
    Celebrim replied to the thread Should PCs Be Exceptional?.
    Even Luke isn't a complete N00b. Biggs, who has been to the Imperial Academy and thus been formally trained, and who is competent...
  • Celebrim
    Celebrim reacted to TwoSix's post in the thread Should PCs Be Exceptional? with Like Like.
    Obviously the first. The second is a pernicious myth that contributes to “hustle culture” and other societal ills.
  • Celebrim
    Celebrim replied to the thread Should PCs Be Exceptional?.
    In any system I like the PC to be slightly above average to begin the game. In D&D in particular, with its Bildungsroman and Heroes'...
Top