Celebrim's latest activity

I think the reason they get dragged along with it for folks who come from other, non-narrative-game perspectives is that these...

I mean if I'm engaged in Trad Play it doesn't matter if I think the scene would get cooler if even more orcs showed up from the next...

This is a good point. It's probably best to not begin a discussion without defining terms. I was assuming that "narrative game"...

It doesn't have anything to do with whether you are railroaded or not. If you track back the conversation, in fact my post was about...

Errr... maybe people do value animals more than people, but in your example your reasoning is wrong. The reason you are fined more for...

I thought the reason was you could cast Raise Dead on a porter, but not on a horse.

This is why you hire hirelings. Porters are much cheaper than a horse, and you form less of an emotional attachment to them so it pains...

The porter's union would like to have a chat with you.

deleted duplicate post.

This probably deserves a fork to a new thread, but that is not the goal of narrative games. And in fact, that's opposite the goal of...

Thank you again for your opinion. I have been I think patient and jocular with your japes about my prolix writing, even making fun of...

This is literally the second time people have repeated my own argument back to me. ""get off at any time" is functionally an agreement...

Because not every GM is ready to improvise something entirely different than what they had prepared for the session. And the Tomb was...

So in other words you are going to "disagree" and then repeat back to me what I just said to you: "get off at any time" is functionally...

I don't think we can in general say that. "Tomb of Horrors" is a very linear adventure for the most part. With a few exceptions in the...