Chaltab's latest activity

Shardminds weren't from 4E Dark Sun, they were from Players Handbook 3. They came up here because I mentioned adding them as a faction...

Okay but you understand why a game with PVP balance (IE power parity with the outcome based entirely on skill & luck) is not the desired...

I have several options in my A5e 3pp/homebrew compilation that work for Goliath.

I mean yeah, they only appeared as PCs in one book in a relatively unpopular edition. But I'd never heard of them being actively...

...what else would High Difficulty mean? If the encounter is guaranteed to kill off your PCs then it's not high difficulty, it's impossible.

Honestly if I were just running a Dark Sun one-shot I would probably use A5E since it has the armor material rules by default and has a...

Which is ironically their own damn fault because of the OGL crisis and the other bad behavior of the past several years.

If I was a 6E designer the last thing I would do would be listen to ENworld lol. A good chunk here are not actively playing or...

Draw Steel is close to 4e. Proof that 4e was a style that a noticable part of the community wanted. It was just too early and lacked...

It failed to make Daddy Hasbro happy but it found and audience and wasn't unprofitable. It just wasn't profitable enough for the...

I had never known they were unpopular, TBH. They were at least popular enough to get multiple 5E homebrew conversions. I always...

I really don't want to rehash edition war nonsense. My point wasn't even that 4E was a resounding success (obviously it wasn't) but that...

Basically. WOTC didn't think anyone would want the Gamer Girl Bathwater of 3rd Edition and Paizo saw a golden opportunity. :ROFLMAO:

Except Patfhinder 1E also failed to address many of the balance issues. I would argue that they were so fundamental that a drastic...

How do you mean this? Was 4E not literally designed to address the common pain points of 3E? Imbalanced classes, too many skills, trap...