Charlaquin's latest activity

I just headcanon them to estocs

A good point well made. I definitely need to tone down my rhetoric.

I’m not just trying to find a technical way to justify an exploit. This is the genuine, good-faith interpretation I have arrived at...

You’re on page 23 of a thread arguing about whether or not it is. So, let’s go with “unclear.”

It would. If that was the intent. It may not have been. I don’t believe it was.

Except that it's not a workaround. It takes your Concentration, which is a big cost, and your Reaction, which is often used by both...

Assuming for the sake of argument that your interpretation is the intended one, and Ready is not meant to be an Action itself, then I...

And frankly, I don't want to play with someone who's so determined to be right that they can't move past a rule. TTRPGs are a...

You won me over with your last paragraph. There will always be disagreements in a game, but there has to be someone who makes the final...

I don’t dispute that. The text of the Ready Action says that you cast the spell on your turn, therefore casting a spell on your turn is...

But you would have to spend the resource when you use the item as a Reaction. So you can’t use Action Surge to cast a spell on your...

It assumes that they wrote the rules the way they did on purpose. If one believes them to have been written in error, or simply dislikes...

It doesn’t say the Magic Action happens as normal, it says you cast the spell as normal. Casting the spell is part of the effect of the...

It defaults to magic action because casting a spell uses the magic action.

Yes, and they also tell you to do that Action later, in response to the trigger, not immediately on your turn. If you did it immediately...