CreamCloud0's latest activity

of course they are completely able to judge when the right time for them to enter should be, however this still gives them absolutely...

The issue with the sim agenda is that 'hoping for an encounter' shouldn't change your probabilities of it occurring.

The same issue applies. If it's my skill to be 'cool under fire' then it shouldn't influence my chance of someone coming in at that...

nah, it was healing elixir i was thinking of, i looked it up afterwards

I mean, we've already demonstrated we are fine with cooks on random encounter rolls, we are fine with cooks in the kitchen at dinner...

Exactly this. The part that conflicts with the sim agenda is that the represented skill at lock-picking (or whatever skill) influences...

This is pretty wrong. If the DM failed to note than the grass on the plains the party entered was very tall when they initially...

There is no pretense. Rolling specifically for a random encounter is very different than having an encounter because you decided to...

I missed this earlier. As the person who came up with the high grass, I specifically mentioned it as being narrated prior to the...

okay but this is part of the core problem you're missing, yes, the dice roll to unlock the door is something that should be influenced...

This example would only have been relevant if somehow you on success the grass had to be short. The entire problem is arising when the...

Who said it"suddenly becomes long" I would never describe its length at all unless asked. It would always be long, but described as a...

What makes you think the two situations are the same? The only way they could be the same is if the cook was a wandering monster and...

I think you are purposfully twisting "made up for the pc" here. While it technically is true in the everyday meaning of these words...

Then take your pick of already narrated features that would work. Nothing has to retroactively happen.