CreamCloud0's latest activity

100% If you were more skilled on that attempt, you would have kept the rope away from that sharp edge. Were you more skilled on that...

In my preference for games I play, on either side of the screen? Pretty much, yeah.

The exact phrasing doesn't matter, because people aren't machines who spit out the exact perfect phrase every time. I don't know what...

It does if the players are doing it. So yeah, the role of the participants matters. Go figure.

I didn't remember the exact wording but the result is the same. The phrasing doesn't really matter, the player is obviously going to...

Substitute "Gee, I sure wish" with "Guessed". Poe-tae-toe poe-tah-toe.

I think the issue is that a mechanic has no information attached to it in any game that I've seen. It will always have other words...

Why do people always feel compelled to tell people that don't like some aspect of the game that they like such as player authoring world...

With this, I agree. But I'm not sure of its relevance to player agency. If all you're suggesting is that the GM keep parts of the map...

More "You're invited to adventure in this world I've provided for you. You're free to accept or decline" I think, because this happens...

For me it's a matter of degree. I would have no problem with a character walking into the bar and then describing basics while staying...

For sure. My feeling, though, is that if you are hitting your personal threshold and we haven't gotten to a bad extreme, then you...

For me this approaches the line, but I don't think it crosses it. I'd prefer for the GM to have many of these details fixed. For...

But how about people that want absolute power over a fiction? What about people that want someone else to have absolute power over a...

Fair enough. I have explained more than once in this eternal thread that I don't desire player collaboration in worldbuilding in games...