CreamCloud0's latest activity

Not by RAW. By RAW you can do it in one action, which is 6 seconds. It takes that 6 seconds skilled, less skilled, or non-skilled...

(the bolded words seem very challenging to me, but I will answer my best) I guess the best way to put it, and answer your question...

Didn't see that one, and I don't agree with your premise that the GM can decide to not accept player action in the game that falls...

To me this whole argument seems to be you telling folks that no matter what, the GM needs to accommodate the player's creative desire...

bad luck is fine for climbing, bad luck is fine for lockpicking too, however, the existence of a cook is not a consequence of bad luck...

So you're saying I'm supposed to play favourites among the players? Accommodate for one but not for another? 'Cause that's how this reads.

Their characters are pretty much interchangeable widgets. The players, not so much.

Well, to me it is. Just because something isn't remembered doesn't mean it never happened.

100% If you were more skilled on that attempt, you would have kept the rope away from that sharp edge. Were you more skilled on that...

In my preference for games I play, on either side of the screen? Pretty much, yeah.

The exact phrasing doesn't matter, because people aren't machines who spit out the exact perfect phrase every time. I don't know what...

It does if the players are doing it. So yeah, the role of the participants matters. Go figure.

I didn't remember the exact wording but the result is the same. The phrasing doesn't really matter, the player is obviously going to...

Substitute "Gee, I sure wish" with "Guessed". Poe-tae-toe poe-tah-toe.

I think the issue is that a mechanic has no information attached to it in any game that I've seen. It will always have other words...