CreamCloud0's latest activity

Eberron would like to have a word with you. Hell, Tolkien would like to have a word with you. Elves, dwarves, orcs, men, hobbits...

Though there is the everpresent chicken-and-the-egg issue there. Or, I guess, more farmer-and-field. A field doesn't grow if the farmer...

although, if you did make a 'made for 5e' setting, they wouldn't need to keep being that.

Are they forbidden from being from the Ten Towns? Is it absolutely carved in stone that they MUST be from parts unknown? That they...

Yup. They are. One of the PC's has ties to the Cassalantar family in Waterdeep. Another is tied to the Gralhund family. One PC has...

Again, to be absolutely clear, not a single person is arguing that any of this NEEDS to be true. What we want is that it CAN be true...

i'm not just talking about the hobbits who are intentionally, specifically out of place (but not totally entirely foreign) to greater...

That's .... not true at all. Phandelver - you can certainly be FROM Phandelver or any of the nearby towns or Neverwinter if you chose...

i do think maybe more weapons should be feasible to use as casting focii, maybe the wizard can use rogue's knives to cast as 'ritual...

and that is significant about them in the context of middle earth, they are not well known, they are not doers of great deeds, they are...

i wonder if they should've made casting focii like, a weapon category(or categorized like weapons are), rather than objects, just to...

War Caster does not permit someone using a weapon-and-shield or two-weapon fighting to use a material focus without sheathing or...

I think that, in general, the desire for the setting to offer hooks to player options is very understandable. I support the general...

i probably should've replied to this as part of my last post no, it didn't impede your ability to play an elf, but do you not think that...

we want to be able to choose to tangibly be from the place we're adventuring in, to have pre-established ties, dynamics and histories...