Crimson Longinus's latest activity

This seems to be an assumption. Some people enjoy DM curated campaign settings and value what those DMs do to make the game good for...

I think if you present your campaign idea up front and any good DM would in my playstyle then it is the player who is behaving badly if...

I don't think the player wanting to ignore the setting and/or campaign concept is "a mild request." People who want to play wookiee jedi...

But does it not then rather make it mechanics driven rather than player driven, if we use the same criteria for how to designate a "driver"?

I don't see a significant difference here, nor with these and 5e. In all cases we have numerical measure of diegetic character...

What is incoherent how you deem this criteria to be satisfied. You made statements about what is simulation and what is not. You think...

This is the exact reason my world now has sand skiff riding desert pirates!

The kinds of players I look for are those who want to be invested in the world. They ask questions about the world before they come up...

I think good DMs are rare period. Well, if the DM goes to the trouble of building an extensive and deep campaign, I think we should...

I saw this now. I think I might have a relevant point before diving to deep into this rabit hole. I would claim neither text nor play...

Data can support me in making a decission. Data does not make a decission itself. A random roll might support me in making a more...

As a player, I expect the GM to allow or disallow PC races based on their world building. There is no reason they have to allow all...

Have you tried to look deeper, to see if there are any attempt at improved coherence? For instance the profilering of player spieces has...

What is the reason for the player to insist on playing dragonborn, that is not similarly a red flag for allowing them into the campaign?

You claimed, way back then, that D&D was bad/difficult for sandbox games because it took too long. Many of us said "So what? We don't...